State of Bitcoin: 2023

Thesis_Mark_-_White.png
photo_2025-11-09 13.37.05.jpeg
puppet.png

A Report by:
Thesis*, Vaish Puri, Joey Campbell

Date:
December 13, 2023

Bitcoin started 2023 in crypto winter and ended above $40,000—but price was just the surface. The year marked Bitcoin's transformation from simple peer-to-peer cash into a programmable foundation for digital artifacts, complex applications, and decentralized finance, all without changing the base protocol.

Ordinals Rewrote Bitcoin's Possibilities

The Ordinals Protocol turned individual satoshis into unique digital artifacts by inscribing them with rich data—text, images, and code permanently stored on-chain. Over 11 million ordinals were created in 2023, generating $725 million in trading volume and sparking fierce debate about Bitcoin's purpose. Recursive ordinals pushed capabilities further, enabling developers to chain data calls and circumvent the 4MB limit, laying groundwork for applications and even games hosted entirely on Bitcoin. What began as digital collectibles evolved into infrastructure for complex on-chain computation.

Bitcoin Self-Custody Reached Historic Levels

While ordinals dominated headlines, on-chain data revealed Bitcoin's strongest supply dynamics ever. Over 76% of circulating supply remained unmoved for at least five months—long-term holders accumulated relentlessly during price consolidation while exchange balances plummeted to five-year lows. Retail investors holding 0.01-0.1 BTC grew steadily alongside institutional wallets above 100 BTC, creating a supply squeeze across all holder types. The migration from exchanges to self-custody accelerated, with investors choosing direct control over intermediary platforms despite macro uncertainty.

BitVM: Smart Contracts On Bitcoin Without Soft Forks

Robin Linus's BitVM proposal shocked the Bitcoin development community by demonstrating Turing-complete computation using Bitcoin's existing script—no consensus changes required. This optimistic rollup-style construction enables complex applications including trustless bridges, derivatives, and prediction markets through a prover-verifier model where false claims get slashed. While still early and limited to two-party schemes, BitVM proved Bitcoin's script more capable than most developers imagined, opening research directions previously considered impossible.

Layer 2 Ecosystems Matured

Stacks shipped major upgrades including decentralized mining and sBTC bridges to port Bitcoin liquidity into sophisticated applications. Rootstock expanded its EVM-compatible sidechain despite ongoing bootstrapping challenges. ZK-rollup teams including Sovereign and Chainway laid foundations for validity proofs on Bitcoin, while Taproot Assets introduced a meta-protocol for issuing arbitrary tokens that integrate natively with Lightning Network—enabling multi-asset Bitcoin applications without network congestion.

Tokenized Bitcoin Unlocked DeFi Liquidity

Tokenized Bitcoin reached $7+ billion across DeFi protocols, with WBTC dominating despite centralization concerns and tBTC gaining ground as the decentralized alternative. Babylon introduced remote staking—allowing BTC holders to secure Proof-of-Stake chains while maintaining custody on Bitcoin, generating yield without bridges or custodians. The concept of "Bitcoin as collateral" expanded beyond wrappers into stablecoins like USDe and crvUSD, where 30-60% of backing came from BTC.

Consumer Applications Bridged Bitcoin to Daily Life

Fold approached one million users earning Bitcoin cashback on everyday purchases, processing nearly $1.5B in transactions. Lolli expanded from web-only to 900+ retail locations across the U.S. Bitrefill launched bill payment services accepting Bitcoin for credit cards, utilities, and mortgages. These applications made Bitcoin accumulation passive and practical, onboarding users who would never touch an exchange.

BRC-20 Tokens and Market Dynamics

BRC-20 fungible tokens emerged as ordinals' cousin, with $ORDI leading the market at $1.4B market cap despite 62% crashes from May highs. The protocol sparked controversy over network congestion and fees—temporarily pushing miner revenue from fees above 75% during peak activity. Critics called it spam; supporters highlighted sustainable fee markets and permissionless innovation testing Bitcoin's limits.

Technical Foundations Strengthened

Taproot adoption accelerated as ordinals and BRC-20s leveraged the upgrade's expanded data capacity. SegWit's 2017 foundation enabled the inscription model that made ordinals possible. Miniscript unlocked advanced wallet architectures for collaborative custody. RGB protocols enabled scalable smart contracts off the base layer. Each innovation built on Bitcoin's existing capabilities without requiring consensus changes—demonstrating the power of building within constraints.

Regulatory Landscape in Flux

While spot ETF approval remained uncertain through 2023, institutional interest surged. SEC filings mentioning Bitcoin hit all-time highs in November. MicroStrategy accumulated 402,100 BTC through convertible notes. GBTC discount narrowed as redemption expectations grew. Global regulatory approaches diverged—El Salvador embraced Bitcoin as legal tender while China banned mining and trading, creating a fragmented landscape for innovation and adoption.

What This Means for Bitcoin's Future

2023 proved Bitcoin's base layer need not change for innovation to flourish. Ordinals, BitVM, and Taproot Assets demonstrated that Bitcoin's existing script and data structures contain unexplored potential. Self-custody trends and holder conviction suggest long-term believers are accumulating regardless of short-term price action. The foundations laid in 2023—from ordinals infrastructure to Layer 2 maturity to consumer application growth—position Bitcoin for its next adoption wave.

Download the full State of Bitcoin 2023 report:

  • Technical deep-dives on Ordinals Protocol, recursive inscriptions, and BRC-20 tokens
  • On-chain analysis revealing holder accumulation patterns and exchange exodus data
  • Comprehensive coverage of BitVM's prover-verifier model and smart contract implications
  • Detailed examination of Layer 2 solutions: Stacks, Rootstock, Lightning, and emerging rollups
  • Market analysis of Bitcoin wrappers, staking protocols, and cross-chain liquidity
  • Case studies on Fold, Taproot Wizards, and consumer applications driving real-world adoption
  • Expert insights from Thesis researchers and Bitcoin ecosystem contributors
State of Bitcoin: 2023 | Thesis